What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
The statistics look damning: the share of Americans who read for pleasure on an average day has fallen by more than 40 per cent over the past 20 years, according to research published in iScience this year.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
A recent Substack essay by James Marriott proclaimed the arrival of a ‘post-literate society’ and invited us to accept this as a fait accompli. (Marriott does also write for The Times.) The diagnosis is familiar: technology has fundamentally degraded our capacity for sustained thought, and there’s nothing to be done except write elegiac essays from a comfortable distance.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
in a pattern so consistent it reveals something essential about how cultural elites respond to changes in how knowledge moves through society.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
In the 18th and early 19th centuries, novel-reading itself was the existential threat. The terms used were identical to today’s moral panic: ‘reading epidemic’, ‘reading mania’, ‘reading rage’, ‘reading fever’, ‘reading lust’, ‘insidious contagion’. The journal Sylph worried in 1796 that women ‘of every age, of every condition, contract and retain a taste for novels … the depravity is universal.’
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
Arthur Schopenhauer in 1851 described ‘bad books’ as ‘intellectual poison’. If the manipulative potential of novels were truly that great, as one historian dryly notes, women would have been eloping in hordes.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
The disaster never materialised. But the panic served its purpose.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
Today, the Cato Institute’s research on historical literacy notes that in the 17th and 18th centuries, ‘some people considered literacy’s spread subversive or corrupting. The expansion of literacy from a tiny elite to the general population scared a lot of conservatives.’
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
compulsory attendance was formalised by the 1880 Education Act, and late-Victorian schooling became entangled with anxiety about what newly literate working-class children were reading – with ‘penny dreadfuls’ and ‘reading trash’ a recurring target of cultural commentary and educational concern. The panic wasn’t really about literacy declining. It was about literacy escaping elite control.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
Socrates worried that writing would ‘produce forgetfulness in the minds of those who learn to use it, because they will not practise their memory.’ He feared readers would ‘seem to know many things, when they are for the most part ignorant’, and warned about confusion and moral disorientation. The irony, as the scholar Walter Ong noted in 1985, is that the weakness in Plato’s position is putting these misgivings about writing into writing.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
Amy Orben, a psychologist studying technology panics, identifies the ‘Sisyphean cycle’: each generation fears new media will corrupt youth; politicians exploit these fears while deflecting from systemic issues like inequality and educational underfunding; research begins too late; and by the time evidence accumulates showing mixed effects dependent on context, a new technology emerges and the cycle restarts.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
Each panic uses identical rhetoric: addiction metaphors, moral corruption, passive victimhood, apocalyptic predictions. Each time, the research eventually shows complex effects mediated by content, context and individual differences. And, each time, when the disaster fails to materialise, attention simply shifts to the next technology.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
What’s different now isn’t the existence of shallow content, which has always been abundant. What’s different is the existence of delivery mechanisms actively engineered to prevent the kind of attention that serious thought requires.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
Others are drowning, attempting sustained thought in environments engineered to prevent it. They sit with laptops open, seven tabs competing for attention, notifications sliding in from three different apps, phones vibrating every few minutes. They’re trying to read serious material while fighting a losing battle against behavioural psychology weaponised at scale. They believe their inability to focus is a personal failure rather than a design problem. They don’t realise they’re trying to think in a space optimised to prevent thinking.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
The pattern I observe repeatedly: people who ‘can’t focus’ on traditional texts can maintain extraordinary concentration when working across modes. They struggle with philosophy textbooks but thrive when they can listen to lectures while taking visual notes, discuss ideas in study groups, and write while pacing. This isn’t deficit. It’s difference. And our responsibility is to build environments where that difference becomes an asset rather than an obstacle.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
Digital documents do this as effectively as paper. The problem is that most digital engagement isn’t writing-based. It’s consumption of algorithmically curated feeds optimised by sophisticated behavioural engineering to maximise time-on-platform.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
We haven’t become post-literate. We’ve become post-monomodal. Text hasn’t disappeared; it’s been joined by a symphony of other channels.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
The real problem isn’t mode but habitat. We don’t struggle with video versus books. We struggle with feeds versus focus.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
This is where libraries become more essential, not less. The library of the future isn’t a warehouse for books. It’s a gymnasium for attention. It’s where communities go to practise different modes of understanding.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
To name the actors responsible and then treat the outcome as inevitable is to provide them cover. If the crisis is a force of nature, ‘screens’ destroying civilisation like some technological weather system, then there’s nothing to be done but write elegiac essays from a comfortable distance. But if the crisis is the product of specific design choices made by specific companies for specific economic reasons, then those choices can be challenged, regulated, reversed.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
Your inability to focus isn’t a moral failing. It’s a design problem. You’re trying to think in environments built to prevent thinking. You’re trying to sustain attention in spaces engineered to shatter it
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays
Created: 2026-03-20
Books aren’t going anywhere. They remain unmatched for certain kinds of sustained, complex thinking. But they’re no longer the only game in town for serious ideas.
See in context at What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problem | Aeon Essays